We are an informal mathematics and theoretical physics discussion group at Duke University. If you want to be added to the mailing list, please send an email to diracrequest@duke.edu.
We welcome anyone who is willing to give a talk or two. The talks need not be tied to any of the topics below; we are always open to learning new things, but they must be accessible to a graduate student audience composed of both mathematicians and physicists.
This semester we are meeting on Thursdays at 3:30 PM in Physics 298.
Talks
Spring 2020

Renormalization Group and Critical Phenomena  Hanqing Liu
Notes
Talks

January 22, 2019
In the following talks I will give an elementary introduction to the renormalization group(RG) and critical phenomena. In the first talk I will give a brief historical introduction to RG and critical phenomena, from Lorentz and van der Waals, to Wilson. Next, I will illustrate the idea of RG by looking at a simplest example, a twostate Markov process. Then I will use the so called “decimation” approach developed by Kadanoff to calculate the RG equations of 1d and 2d Ising model, and calculate their critical temperatures and critical exponents.

January 30, 2019
I will begin with a more extensive discussion of the Markov chain that I introduced in my last talk. Then I will introduce the 1d Ising model and discuss the decimation RG of this model, the scaling hypothesis, and calculate the critical exponents of the model. If time permits I will talk about the 2d Ising model.

February 6, 2019
This time I will continue talking about the scaling hypothesis. I will show the RG flow of 1d Ising model with external field and calculate the critical exponents. Then I will start talking about the RG of 2d Ising model.

January 22, 2019
Fall 2019

Gerbes  Paul Aspinwall

December 4, 2019
I will show how particle physics on a manifold naturally leads to the idea of a bundle with a connection. The same construction for strings leads to a 2gerbe. The topology of a bundle is encoded in a characteristic class, whereas the topology of the 2gerbe defines an integral element of H^3. The connection is a 2form called the Bfield. I will try to make the talk selfcontained and I’ll probably spend most of the time taking about the 1gerbe picture of a bundle. There will be no categories!

December 4, 2019

Singularities in General Relativity  James Wheeler

October 8, 2019
I’ll introduce the question of what a singularity in General Relativity should be. I’ll discuss the prototypical GR singularity, the Schwarzschild solution, as well as another example or two demonstrating the challenge of analyzing whether a spacetime is singular, especially via coordinate charts. To take a more general approach, I’ll discuss various properties required of a spacetime to make it a physically reasonable model, in particular time orientation, the hierarchy of causality conditions one might require, and timelike geodesic or bundlecompleteness. I’ll again look to examples to demonstrate these properties. Ultimately, I’ll arrive at a reasonable definition of a singular spacetime, and I’ll point to the questions left open by this definition.

October 22, 2019
This week, I’ll begin by recalling our definition of a singular spacetime and the primary questions it leaves open that we’d like to address. In particular, I’ll discuss the question of “where” singularities are by giving a brief overview of the alphabet of boundary constructions (any one of which would take a full lecture to describe in detail) that have been attempted as well as their merits and drawbacks. Having addressed this question as best as we can, I’ll then begin the discussion of how serious we need to take singular spacetimes as general relativists, leading to the singularity theorems of Hawking and Penrose.

October 30, 2019
Tomorrow, I’ll finally move past the question of what singularities are, turning instead to the question of why we indeed need to worry ourselves with them when doing General Relativity. The main feature of the discussion will be (finally) Hawking and Penrose’s singularity theorems. Depending on how the timing works out, I may go on to introduce the topic of what we mean by a black hole (more generally than our Schwarzschild prototype) and how the problem of Cosmic Censorship arises out of all that we’ve discussed so far– the bulk of that topic, however, will probably be treated in my final talk next week.

November 12, 2019
This week, I’ll begin by discussing why we call the Schwarzschild solution a “black hole” and how that inspires the Penrose singularity theorem, which I will briefly go over. Having thereby established the general existence of Schwarzschildtype singularities, I’ll then discuss the more general definition of a black hole and how that leads us to the question of the Weak Cosmic Censorship conjecture. In closing, I’ll indicate why this conjecture is important to the viability of GR and some of the progress that has been made.

October 8, 2019

Gravitation  Benjamin Hamm and James Wheeler

August 28, 2019:
Mathematical structure of general relativity I  James Wheeler
Tomorrow, I’ll give a brief review of the mathematical structures underlying General Relativity, at each step giving a physical motivation for invoking the structure. My perspective will be from the standpoint of asking what kind of global structure we can reasonably infer from the local observations we’re limited to making. In particular, I’ll begin with the definition of a smooth manifold and discuss the construction of its tangent space and the notion of a connection. I’ll introduce tensors and why special relativity leads us to expect that a manifold model for the universe should come equipped with a metric tensor. Finally, I’ll introduce the LeviCivita connection and use it to talk about the decomposition of a general connection into its metric compatibility and torsion tensors, demonstrating how torsion can change geodesics when metric compatibility is fixed. This will set the stage for Ben’s discussion, which will culminate in a computation of how light redshift would be different if one takes the geometric motivation of dark matter through the addition of torsion seriously.

September 4, 2019:
Mathematical structure of general relativity II  James Wheeler
I’ll discuss some examples together with some simple explicit computations to demonstrate concepts introduced last week. Having (hopefully) provided a bit of clarity, I’ll complete last week’s discussion by introducing the LeviCivita connection and the decomposition of a general connection into metric compatibility and torsion tensors.

September 10, 2019:
Einstein's Equations, Curvature, and the Hilbert Action  I  Benjamin Hamm
This week I will start with a brief introduction of the Einstein Equations. From here, I will introduce the concepts of parallel transport and geodesic deviation, and ultimately use them to motivate a discussion of the Riemann curvature tensor. I will also provide a brief discussion and description of the stressenergy tensor. Finally, time provided, this will allow us to return to the discussion of the EinsteinEquations and motivate the form for the EinsteinHilbert Action. Looking forward, this will motivate a discussion of how the action may be modified to include torsion, and the results of doing so.

September 18, 2019:
Einstein's Equations, Curvature, and the Hilbert Action  II  Benjamin Hamm
I will continue with a short recap of parallel transport and Riemann curvature. From here I will finally introduce the stressenergy tensor and the notion of energymomentum conservation. We will then derive the Einstein equation from the Hilbert Action, and discuss the fact that the Hilbert Action is the most general action of its type. We will then be able to discuss the various ways that the action may be modified in order to attain alternative theories of Gravity. Then, given time, we will discuss a particular case of such modification, often referred to as the “Wave Dark Matter” or “Fuzzy Dark Matter” theory.

September 24, 2019:
Einstein's Equations, Curvature, and the Hilbert Action  III  Benjamin Hamm
This week we will finally discuss the EinsteinHilbert Action in more detail. Starting with a brief recap of where we arrived last week, I will restate the axioms which produce the usual form of the action. From here I will point out a few ways that people have considered modifying the action, and the theories which result from doing so. I will then end with the example of Wave Dark Matter, a theory identical to General Relativity, but with a nontrivial torsion tensor.

August 28, 2019:
Mathematical structure of general relativity I  James Wheeler
Spring 2019

Projective Representations in Quantum Mechanics  Paul Aspinwall

March 20, 2019:
Projective Representations in QM
I will describe the issue of projective representations in QM. For finite dimensional symmetry groups this idea leads to the familiar notion of spin, but for infinite dimensional groups the issue is more subtle. This leads to a nice way of understanding why “central charges” appear in symmetry algebras and I’ll go through the example of the Virasoro algebra.

April 3, 2019:
Projective Representations in QM
In the last lecture I introduced the abstract idea of projective representations of a Lie algebra. This is trivial for the familiar examples of finitedimensional simple groups (like, SU(2), SU(3), etc.). This talk I’ll go through the Virasoro algebra (key in string theory and twodimensional conformal field theories) and show it’s not trivial, and very important!

April 10, 2019:
Bosonization
I’ll give a “physics proof” of the Jacobi Triple Product formula and then apply it to bosons and fermions in 2 dimensional conformal field theory. Lots of fun number theory!

March 20, 2019:
Projective Representations in QM

Quantum Symmetries and Twisted Equivariant Representations  Akos Nagy
Akos Nagy will resume his series of talks titled “Quantum Symmetries and twisted equivariant representations.”
Talks

February 6, 2019
In the first talk Akos will review what he talked about last year, namely how symmetries can be represented in QM, and how these representations canonically fall into 10=8+2 classes, labelled by Clifford algebras.
 February 13, 2019
 February 27, 2019

February 6, 2019

Intro to Topological Insulators  Alexander Watson
Alexander Watson will finish up the series of talks on topological insulators that he started last semester.
Notes
Talks

January 16, 2019
I will recap: (1) the strangeness of the quantum Hall and related effects (transverse conductivity proportional to an integer) (2) Bloch (band) theory (3) how the quantum anomalous Hall effect is related with integrating a curvature over a closed surface (yielding an integer: the Chern number). I will then introduce the Haldane model, a tightbinding (discrete) model of a hypothetical 2d material which exhibits the quantum anomalous Hall effect where the Chern number can be computed relatively easily and verified nonzero. If there is time I will discuss the edges of such materials where very robust currents propagate. The robustness of these currents has stimulated recent interest for applications.
 January 23, 2019

January 30, 2019
I will describe the Haldane model which describes a hypothetical material which would exhibit the quantum anomalous Hall effect, a quantum Hall effect which does not require a magnetic field through the material. Such materials are now known as topological insulators.

January 16, 2019
Fall 2018

Quantum Symmetries Revisited, Part I  Akos Nagy
In the next few talks, I will be talk about symmetries of quantum (mechanical) systems and how they relate to the topological phases of matter, following the highly influential paper of Freed and Moore [1]. In the first talk, I will have a more nuanced look at what constitutes as a “quantum symmetry”, and extend the usual notion of only unitary symmetries that commute with the Hamiltonian. This is not entirely new to physicists, part of it was know since Dyson’s famous 3fold way. Mathematically, Dyson’s 3fold way is the trichotomy of real, complex, and quaternionic representations. The detailed analysis of Freed and Moore gives a nice and complete understanding of quantum symmetries, and generalizes Dyson’s result to a 10fold way. The 10 = 8+2 ways correspond to the 8+2 (Morita)equivalence classes of Clifford algebras, and gives a mathematically clear understanding of Kitaev’s periodic table [2].
[1] D. S. Freed and G. W. Moore: Twisted equivariant matter, Annales Henri Poincare, Volume 14, pages 19272023, (2013)
[2] A. Y. Kitaev: Periodic table for topological insulators and superconductors, AIP Conf. Proc., Volume 1134, pages 2230, (2009)Talks
 November 28, 2018
 December 5, 2018

Intro to Topological Insulators  Alexander Watson
The experimental observation and subsequent theoretical investigation of the quantum Hall effect showed that a surprising connection exists between condensed matter physics (roughly, the study of why matter behaves as it does) and topology. Specifically, it was found that under appropriate conditions part of the resistivity (roughly, the response of electrons in the material to an applied electric field) of certain twodimensional materials must be exactly proportional to an integer. This integer was later understood as the first Chern number of a certain vector bundle associated to the atomic structure of the material. In these talks I will explain, starting from basic electromagnetism and quantum mechanics, how this correspondence arises. I will then discuss some of the interest in such materials (known as “topological insulators”) for applications.
Notes
Talks
 November 12, 2018
 November 19, 2018
 November 26, 2018
 December 3, 2018

String Theory  Ronen Plesser

October 31, 2018
Ronen Plesser will discuss the basics of string theory. It is going to be an introduction equally accessible to both mathematicians and physicists and no background in either string theory or advanced geometry will be necessary.

November 7, 2018
Ronen Plesser will continue his introduction to string theory. For those who missed last week’s talk, Ronen is basing his discussion on Edward Witten’s “What every physicist should know about string theory”
 November 14, 2018

October 31, 2018

Braids and the Yang Baxter equation  Orsola CapovillaSearle
Orsola CapovillaSearle will give a series of talks on “Braids and the Yang Baxter equation.” She will give an outline of how braids are related to the solution of the Yang Baxter equation. Orsola has promised that the talks would be accessible to everyone.
Talks

Foundations of Quantum Mechanics  Hersh Singh
References
 Sydney Coleman  Quantum Mechanics In Your Face
 N. David Mermin  Quantum mysteries revisited
 David Tong  Notes on Foundations of Quantum Mechanics
 David Z. Albert  Quantum Mechanics and Experience
Talks

September 19, 2018
I’ll start with the very basics and discuss some simple thought experiments that illustrate the weirdness of quantum mechanics and the need for it. I will then introduce the postulates of QM and dwell on them for a bit. This should set the stage for discussing the “EPR paradox” and it’s conclusion with the Bell inequality, which we will probably get to next week.
Tomorrow’s talk will require absolutely no prior knowledge of quantum mechanics.

September 26, 2018
I’ll discuss the EPR paradox and describe a simpler version of Bell’s argument (sometimes called the GHZM experiment) that shows, yet again, how quantum mechanics is weird.

October 9, 2018
Tomorrow I’ll conclude my talks, on the foundations of quantum mechanics, with the GHZM experiment.
Spring 2018

BRST  Ronen Plesser

April 27, 2018
Tomorrow I will continue the discussion of BRST quantization. I will show how BRS and T found the fermionic symmetry in the path integral approach to quantizing gauge theory, and try to compare to the symplectic approach we learned in Paul’s lectures.

April 27, 2018

Anomalies in Physics  Ronen Plesser

April 9, 2018
I want to try to explain what anomalies tell us about physics. Some of this is a bit off the mathematical physics path we have been following, but it seems to me that it belongs in the series. In particular, I want to say something about: (a) How the chiral anomaly is related to pion decay (b) What anomalies in global symmetries tell us  ‘tHooft matching, anomaly cancellations. (c) How SM anomalies break Lepton number (d) What the anomaly has to do with the theta angle and instantons.
 April 23, 2018

April 9, 2018

Feynman Diagrams from the BV Formalism  Eugene Rabinovich
References
 An expository article by Owen Gwilliam, Theo JohnsonFreyd
 A Note on the Antibracket Formalism  Edward Witten
Talks

April 6, 2018
Eugene Rabinovich will tell us more about the BatalinVilkovisky formalism in QFT and show, with a simple example, how it encodes information about the path integral.

BRST  Paul Aspinwall
References
Talks

March 23, 2018
I’ll do the purely classical version of BRST. Ronen will hopefully do the path integral version later. For those who’ve never heard of BRST, it’s kind of central to string theory and topological field theory, not to mention gauge theory.

March 29, 2018
I’ll continue my BRST talks. This will include a description of Lie algebra cohomology and building a double complex to define BRST cohomology.

April 20, 2018
Today I’ll finish my BRST talks. If you remember I’d written down two complexes. I’ll remind of these, write them as a double complex and get the BRST operator that QFT people will recognize. I’ll give some examples to show it’s not quite what the QFT people ordered.

March 23, 2018

Conformal Perturbation Theory  Ilarion Melnikov

March 2, 2018
I will sketch out how conformal perturbation theory (CPT) should fit into the framework of renormalizable quantum field theory. CPT is expected to have some remarkable properties, especially when compared to perturbative quantum field theory computations. I will review some of these conjectured properties and then discuss steps to prove them in the context of twodimensional theories.

March 2, 2018

Characteristic Classes and Index Theory  Matthew Beckett
Thanks to Orsola CapovillaSearle for the beautiful notes!
Talks

February 16, 2018:
Characteristic classes 1
I will be giving the first few talks, with the eventual goal of talking about index theorems. This Friday I will take the first step in that direction by talking about characteristic classes.

February 23, 2018:
Characteristic classes 2
My plan is to wade a little deeper into the subject of characteristic classes, building on Chern classes to define Pontrjagin classes, and then talk about Chern and Pontrjagin genera.

March 8, 2018:
Clifford Actions
I will be discussing Clifford actions on vector bundles, Dirac operators, and, time permitting, spinor bundles.

March 26, 2018:
Index Theorem
I will give a bit more detail about spinor bundles and talk a little of their topology. I should then have everything I need in order to state the index theorem.

February 16, 2018:
Characteristic classes 1
Fall 2017

Path Integrals in Quantum Mechanics  Paul Aspinwall
Thanks to Mendel Nguyen for the notes!
Talks

October 23, 2017:
Path Integrals in Quantum Mechanics
Tomorrow Paul Aspinwall will start his talks on quantum mechanics.

November 6, 2017:
Path Integrals in Quantum Mechanics
Paul Aspinwall will continue with his series on quantum mechanics.

November 13, 2017:
Path Integrals in Quantum Mechanics
I’ll continue with the Feynman path integral and then start talking about Norbert Wiener’s version.

November 27, 2017:
Path Integrals in Quantum Mechanics
Paul Aspinwall will continue with his series on quantum mechanics.

October 23, 2017:
Path Integrals in Quantum Mechanics

Anomalies  Hersh Singh
References
 Weinberg  The Quantum Theory of Fields Vol. 2, Chapter 21
 Bilal  Lectures on Anomalies
Talks

October 5, 2017:
Path Integral Formulation of QFT
With the goal of eventually understanding anomalies in quantum field theory, I will start talking about quantum field theory. I am still trying to figure out the minimal subset of QFT that we will need. But at the bare minimum, we will need to talk about the path integral formulation, so that’s where we will start. We will also discuss the symmetries of a Lagrangian, and how they give us conservation laws by Noether’s theorem. An important question to ask: Is a classical symmetry of the Lagrangian also a symmetry of the quantum theory? (Hint: This is how anomalies get their name.)

October 12, 2017:
Path Integral Formulation of QFT
Hersh will continue with his talks and will introduce the path integral formalism. Let’s meet in the faculty lounge at 5 pm as usual.

October 19, 2017:
Path Integral Formulation of QFT
Hersh will set up the path integral formalism in QFT and introduce the Dirac equation if he can get to it.

October 26, 2017:
The Dirac Equation
Hersh will discuss the Dirac equation.

November 9, 2017:
The Abelian Anomaly
Having delayed the goal of discussing anomalies in quantum field theory by several ‘background’ talks, tomorrow I’ll finally drop into the middle of the action and start talking about the abelian anomaly. Among other things, it will lead us into good math.

November 16, 2017:
The Abelian Anomaly
Tomorrow I’ll continue with the abelian anomaly and derive the index theorem.

November 30, 2017:
The Index Theorem
Hersh will probably complete his series on anomalies.

Constrained Dynamics  Travis Maxfield
Notes
Talks

September 18, 2017
Travis Maxfield will talk about singular hamiltonians which should be the perfect continuation of what Orsola started last week.

September 21, 2017
Travis will discuss some of the confusing issues about the toy model Lagrangian he constructed in Tuesday’s talk.

October 2, 2017
Travis Maxfield of CGTP will talk about singular hamiltonians (constrained dynamics).

September 18, 2017

Symplectic Geometry  Orsola CapovillaSearle

September 14, 2017:
Symplectic Geometry
I’m going to go over some of the basic definitions of symplectic geometry. I will also look at how it was first developed in Hamiltonian mechanics, and discuss Poisson brackets and Noethers theorem. I will also indicate some of the key differences between Riemannian geometry to which were are more accustomed to and symplectic geometry.

September 14, 2017:
Symplectic Geometry
Spring 2017

General Relativity with Torsion  Benjamin Hamm

June 14, 2017
I plan to cover the basic axioms/assumptions of General Relativity along with some Riemannian geometry. Then, given time, I will cover metric compatible, torsionfree gravitation and then a theory which uses neither assumption.

June 14, 2017

Principal Bundles  Matthew Beckett
References
 I originally learned from Spivak’s Comprehensive Introduction to Differential Geometry (although it was the very old version).
 I think the material on principal bundles is in Volume II. KobayashiNomizu’s Foundations of Differential Geometry Volume I is a very clean (but opaque) treatment.
 Taubes also has a book called Differential Geometry: Bundles, Connections, Metrics and Curvature, although I am not as familiar with it.
 Also, by popular demand I am attaching my Master’s Thesis. Sections 2.2 and 2.3 are more or less what we covered today. I will cover 3.3 on Friday. Also, section 4 covers a lot of what I went through before on Yang–Mills theory, in case you wanted a review of that.
Talks

May 31, 2017
I will be talking about Principal Bundles. I aim to get through the definitions and some basic examples, and to discuss Associated Vector Bundles.

June 2, 2017
Matthew will talk about connections on principal bundles.

Supersymmetry  Hanqing Liu
Notes
Talks

April 24, 2017:
Supersymmetry
Today I will introduce supersymmetry in 4 dimension. I will first spend quite some time to motivate the supersymmetry, including ColemanMandula theorem and the result of Haag, et al. Then I will review the spin representation of Lorentz group (more precisely, SL(2,C)) with the Van der Waerden notation (dotted and undotted), and derive the super algebra.

April 27, 2017:
Supersymmetry
Today I will first make something clear which was unclear last time, then finish the representation theory of Lorentz group. The next thing is defining the supersymmetry algebra and the Witten index.

May 1, 2017:
Supersymmetry
Things always turn out to be slower than I expect, so today I will finish the remaining stuff: defining the supersymmetry algebra and the Witten index.

April 24, 2017:
Supersymmetry

YangMills  Matthew Beckett

April 13, 2017:
YangMills
I will be talking this evening. I aim to give a brief introduction to YangMills theory. I’m not sure how far I will get, but I aim to derive the YangMills equation and define instantons. Time permitting, I will look a little at the specific case of an SU(2) bundle over S^4.

April 20, 2017:
YangMills
I will start where I left off last week, beginning by deriving the EulerLagrange equation for the YangMills functional. I will then start looking at some properties of instantons, including some topological considerations, and then look at some examples on S^4.

April 13, 2017:
YangMills

Instantons  Hersh Singh

April 6, 2017:
Instantons
Today I’ll start talking about instantons, from chapter 7 in Sydney Coleman’s “Aspects of Symmetry.” I’ll start with a bit of path integrals in quantum mechanics, and talk about how we can recover some well known results in QM by looking from the instanton perspective. The aim of course is to get to instantons in gauge theories, which is where topology comes in, but we’ll see how far I can go today.

April 10, 2017:
Instantons
Today I’ll continue talking about instantons. We’ll discuss a couple of somewhat more nontrivial examples in quantum mechanics. Looking at the doublewell potential, in particular, will clarify the connection of instantons to “tunneling.” Time permitting, we’ll move on to gauge theories. Hopefully, today I’ll be able to set the stage up for that, so that we can discuss the important results next time.

April 6, 2017:
Instantons

Monopoles  Mendel Nguyen
My talk discussed topological conservation laws in gauge theories. In particular, I introduced the ‘t HooftPolyakov monopole.
References:
 S. Coleman, Aspects of Symmetry, Chapter on ‘Lumps’; and
 V. Rubakov, Classical Theory of Gauge Fields
Talks
 March 30, 2017: Monopoles
 April 3, 2017: Monopoles

Cohomology  Arman Margaryan

March 23, 2017:
Cohomology
Since we have done quite a lot of bundle, connection stuff already, Arman will catch us up on the algebraic topology side of things by introducing DeRham cohomology (definition, long exact sequence etc.) and possibly some basics of homotopy today. It is designed to be an introduction for those who haven’t seen much algebraic topology.

March 27, 2017:
Cohomology
Arman is going to carry on about cohomology groups and so on today at 6.

March 23, 2017:
Cohomology

Differential Geometry  Arya Roy

February 13, 2017:
Vector Bundles
Today I will cover the basics of vector bundles on manifolds. I will start with the definition of a differentiable manifold and lay out the basics of the construction of a vector bundle. Then I will give several examples of vector bundles that we will encounter, like the tangent and cotangent bundle, and how to construct new bundles like the direct sum, tensor, exterior power, Hom and the pullback bundle. All of these constructions will be useful later for our applications. Even though it sounds like a long list nothing more than a standard linear algebra background will be necessary.

February 20, 2017
Today I will construct various vector bundles corresponding to the vector space constructions I discussed last Monday. Math grad students might again be bored out of their minds! Once we get past connections and curvature everyone will be on the same page and we can construct the Yang Mills Lagrangian.

March 9, 2017
I will start with the theory of connections on vector bundles and talk about connections on all the bundles I gave constructions for last day. Connections have a couple of equivalent of definitions and I intend to talk about all of them, starting with the most obvious (covariant derivative) as a generalization of derivatives. Later I will talk about how connections can be viewed as a splitting on tangent bundles. I realized I was too quick in my discussion of exterior derivatives on bundles, so I will revisit bundle valued forms and exterior derivatives and finish of connections and curvature.

February 13, 2017:
Vector Bundles